It must've been a mountain, standing in our way
Or some small misunderstanding, we talked about too late
was it the kitchen or the bedroom, where we let a good thing go
Was it different dreams, or space we needed, I don't know

(chorus)
Baby, lately my memory ain't what it used to be at all
It's crazy, holding you close to me, seeing you smile at me is all that I recall
Baby, it don't matter how hard I try
I still can't remember why we said goodbye, goodbye

Maybe time's been playing tricks on me these days
Or maybe these old feelings never went away
But all that I can remember is I'm still in love with you
And if I'm losing my mind, I hope you are too
It's crazy, holding you close to me, seeing you smile is all that I recall
Baby, it don't matter how hard I try
I still can't remember why we said goodbye, why we said goodbye
Why did we say goodbye

(Thanks to Natalie for these lyrics)